Your Selection

By Natalie Smith
Spanning back six generations to the mid-nineteenth century, the story behind this balsamic lineage is fascinating. Giuseppe Pedroni was a boaro, a cowherd who occasionally hauled firewood to local nobles. On one such delivery, a chunk of wall came loose, revealing three numbers scratched into the surface beneath. He decided to play them in the lottery, believing they meant something and crossed his path for a reason. He won. He used his winnings to buy land, planning to secure a better future and story for his family. On the parcel he now owned stood a monastery outbuilding, located in the right place and with the right structure to become a tavern. Giuseppe obtained a license to operate a proper establishment, which he opened to the birocciai, local and travelling cart-drivers who needed stables and a meal during their journeys. Pedroni began officially serving wine and beer that the family had also begun producing.
The new foray into winemaking brought a surplus of empty chestnut Marsala casks, thin and small by nature. German oak beer barrels piled up as well, thicker and larger. Giuseppe's instinct to avoid any unnecessary waste in his new era of foundling fortune pushed him to find a use for these empty containers. They were in continual supply, and given the specific conditions of the estate's terroir that not only determined the type of casks piling up but also, quite importantly, the climate and temperature for ageing any resulting products, balsamic vinegar production at Acetaia Pedroni began. It was almost as an afterthought, as a way to put everything the estate was churning out to use.
Six generations later, Giuseppe III has managed the family estate since 1997. The wine is still made, the balsamic is still produced. Nothing about the process has been rushed, and nothing has been simplified. Every bottle Pedroni produces carries a taste and a touch uniquely theirs. Cooked grape must forms the foundation that continues to build their balsamic to a level that stands apart. Natural evaporation concentrates the flavour over the years, over decades, in cases where the black gold is allowed to continue its slow maturation undisturbed. Production remains small and controlled because the Pedroni family isn't interested in the alternative, which is why it isn't widely known and hasn't burst onto the global markeplace.
The consortium is the only body authorized to authenticate what goes into those distinctive 100ml Giugiaro bottles, custom-designed by Giorgetto Giugiaro and standardized for all certified producers. They legally define, regulate, and protect it. Italy has longstanding traditions of gatekeeping and guarding native products, which is why provenance sings through in local stories like Pedroni's. Two designations exist: affinato, aged a minimum of twelve years, and extra vecchio, aged a minimum of twenty-five. No other age may appear on the label, even if it is suggested. This isn't bureaucratic pedantry; the world sees it so often it becomes assumed and dismissed as unimportant wording. But the painfully specific standards and rules here are real. They protect both the product and the person buying it.
The grey area matters and is worth understanding. There are vinegars drawn from barrels that survived the Second World War. These have rested in their wooden homes for at least eighty-five years, possibly more. Then there is the Cesare reserve, a family collection with barrels reaching back one hundred and seventy years. Chemical analysis can suggest an age, but it cannot legally confirm it. So no number beyond the two that the Consortium permits will appear on any packaging. What you are buying, based on a label, is very simply described as: affinato, extra vecchio. But the weight of everything behind those words, when they come from a family that has been doing this since 1862 with an astounding heritage and origin story, is incredible.


Pedroni's balsamic begins with the Trebbiano di Spagna grape. The traditional name is a bit misleading, as it doesn't come from Spain, but from the Modena area of Emilia-Romagna. It's Italian but extremely rare, with only a few hectares in existence, sporadically found in old Modenese vineyards. On the same land in Rubbiara di Nonantola, inherited by the original Giuseppe, one vineyard of these aromatic white grapes survived.
The fruit has a high natural sugar content, and the vines are sensitive. It fell into serious decline because its flowers are functionally female, so bunches set loosely and the yields are low. After 1919, Modena replanted mainly with Lambrusco, and when the Italian national variety register was established, this little white grape was left off completely. Quite importantly, that made it illegal to replant at all. It's only recently recovered from near extinction after being added back to the Italian national variety register in the 21st century. To put it in perspective, the regional vineyard register has recorded only 11 hectares of Trebbianina, the grape's official name, in recent years. Trebbiano Romagnolo, its neighbour in the same region, covers almost 16,000 hectares. That's 1 vine of Trebbiano di Spagna for every 1,450 Trebbiano Romagnolo.
Pedroni recognised what he had: land and the vines on it, which carried importance directly linked to his family's future with everything it produced. The vineyard was nurtured and protected, the cooked must it produced becoming the defining component of every bottle of vinegar made. The process of producing Pedroni balsamic is unhurried to the point of being almost philosophical. Each year, a small amount is drawn from the oldest barrels for bottling. What remains is topped up from the next barrel in the aging sequence, which is then topped up from the next, and so on. It's a continuous, living chain, refreshed so it can keep moving slowly through time. Liquid that has spent twelve years aging receives affinato DOP approval. Liquid allowed to mature for another thirteen years earns extra vecchio, which means it has spent a minimum of twenty-five years total ageing in the barrels.
And then there is everything else. The balsamic simply continues ageing, undisturbed, in batteries that have rested for decades. As touched upon briefly earlier, the "everything else" lives within the grey area the consortium doesn't label. No official designation exists, and this is why the description matters more than any number. The recognition reflects it, which is why Acetaia Pedroni is among the most decorated producers in the Consorteria di Spilamberto's annual competitions, held to identify the finest traditional balsamic produced within the ancient dominions of the Este family. What distinguishes Pedroni is the particular touch that has passed between generations: the accumulated knowledge of a family that has been managing these barrels, producing black gold since 1862.
A native of Emilia-Romagna, Stefano Bergonzini has spent a lifetime in the company of serious food. He comes from that stretch of northern Italy sandwiched between the Alps and the Apennines, home to some of the most important cuisines that have been recognized and produced. Stefano’s relationship with what he eats and where it comes from precedes his earliest memories. It was shaped in his father's fine food shop in Modena, which was opened in 1963 and eventually became one of the most respected in the region. Stefano began working there in 1983, eventually taking over to run it himself, and has not looked back since. He has only looked for ways to broaden his scope and awareness of food, and more ways in which it can be appreciated and shared.
Nearly four decades of experience in Italian luxury food will do something to a person. It makes you particular. It makes you patient. It makes you useful to people who are working along similar lines within related industries: the producers, the artisans, and the restaurants who seek out his expertise, precisely because he understands what the work and taste level require.
He has spent his life devoted to a cause he considers a calling: the preservation and promotion of Italy's finest, slowest culinary traditions.
